Madisonian dilemma." The United States was founded as a Madisonian system, which means that it contains two opposing principles that must be continually reconciled. The first principle is self-government, which means that in wide areas of life majorities... Guns and Butter: Setting Priorities in Federal Spending in the Context of ... - Page 72by United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs. Subcommittee on Federal Financial Management, Government Information, and International Security - 2006 - 85 pagesFull view - About this book
| Gerald F. Gaus - Political Science - 1996 - 391 pages
...two opposing principles that must be continually reconciled. The first principle is self-government, which means that in wide areas of life majorities...which the individual must be free of majority rule. 50 Bork articulates inadequately the liberal ideal of limited government. His underlying claim is that... | |
| Robert H. Bork - Political Science - 2009 - 452 pages
...two opposing principles that must be continually reconciled. The first principle is self-government, which means that in wide areas of life majorities...which the individual must be free of majority rule. The dilemma is that neither majorities nor minorities can be trusted to define the proper spheres of... | |
| Harry V. Jaffa - Biography & Autobiography - 1999 - 212 pages
...dilemma," according to Bork, is the dilemma of how to reconcile the opposing principles of self rule — "that in wide areas of life majorities are entitled...if they wish, simply because they are majorities" — and the protection of individual rights.34 But as Jaffa cogently argues, there is no hint anywhere... | |
| Robert Justin Lipkin - Law - 2000 - 392 pages
...that Bork contends that the first principle of a Madisonian system is the principle of selfgovernment, "which means that in wide areas of life majorities...if they wish, simply because they are majorities." But the second principle of the Madisonian system "is that there are nonetheless some things majorities... | |
| Jed Rubenfeld - Philosophy - 2008 - 269 pages
..."first principle" of the American "system," Bork writes, "is self-government," which "means that . . . majorities are entitled to rule, if they wish, simply because they are majorities." But there is a "second" principle too: "that there are nonetheless some things majorities must not... | |
| Gerald F Gaus - Political Science - 2003 - 260 pages
...two opposing principles that must be continually reconciled. The first principle is self-government, which means that in wide areas of life majorities...which the individual must be free of majority rule. 48 I believe that this inadequately articulates the liberal ideal of limited government. Bork's underlying... | |
| Robert William Bennett - Democracy - 2003 - 250 pages
...." ; Robert H. Bork, THE TEMPTING OF AMERICA 139 (Free Press 1990): American "self-government. . . means that in wide areas of life majorities are entitled to rule . . . simply because they are majorities"; Steven G. Calabresi, Textualism and the Countermajoritarian... | |
| Mark K. Moller - Law - 2007 - 384 pages
...thought on such matters. America's first principle as a nation, Judge Bork wrote, is self-government, which means "that in wide areas of life majorities...if they wish, simply because they are majorities." Our second principle, he continued, is "that there are nonetheless some things majorities must not... | |
| Bryan Caplan - Philosophy - 2008 - 293 pages
...usually economists themselves who discover the exceptions in the first place. Democratic Fundamentalism In wide areas of life majorities are entitled to rule,...if they wish, simply because they are majorities. — Robert Bork, The Tempting of America15 The disparity between economists' open-mindedness and the... | |
| |