Page images
PDF
EPUB
[graphic]

"That Bright Heat" is the story of Clarion Lawless, who grows up in physical beauty and spiritual turbulence in the St. Louis of the eighteen eighties. His mother had died at his birth and his father, embittered by frustration, in Clarion's early boyhood. Clarion wants "that hard unbroken ecstasy which does not exist for any man." His father, with the same desires, had taken refuge in another creature, Clarion's mother, whose death left him face to face with bleakness.

Clarion seeks the same refuge, but all too blindly, and loses it through his inability to meet anything actual in life. As a boy, he falls in love with Clover Halliday, a high-hearted girl as impatient as he of social restraints, but with a petulant lack of understanding which contributes to the tragedy toward which the story is obviously pointed. Clarion's passion inevitably kills the thing he loves. He waits to declare and at once to consummate his love in one brief hour before Clover's marriage to another man. Then he gives her up, impetuously, because he has lost the family fortune in a mining venture, engineered, it turns out, by a man whom he has once befriended. Clover does not wait the necessary minute for him to change his mind. She marries, bears Clarion's child, and dies without seeing him. Clarion goes away with an octaroon whom he believes to be a Creole, returns presently to find himself ostracized for this breach of good manners, and kills himself in a burning building. The story is further complicated by the incidental appearances of a third woman, a stagy day-dreamer, who imagines herself to be in love with Clarion, collapses at every point where her dreams touch disillusioning reality, and takes to drink. And there is a brief interpolated melodrama of the ruined and embittered poet whose fraudulent mining scheme hastens Clarion's downfall.

This is all, of course, pure allegory. It is written with passionate sincerity, in a fine prose. But its characters have the quality of figures in an allegory. With the best will in the world and some understanding of Clarion's defects and his compensatory qualities, it is not possible to be moved by his tragedy. As a human being, his claim to interest would be as a psychological study; there, he could be analyzed on the simplest Freudian basis. As a figure in an allegory he symbolizes the revolter against social usage, the man who cannot be satisfied with the outward aspect of things and people, the tragic seeker after spiritual values in a material world-above all, as the man so dazzled by that bright heat which is life as to be blind to that smoky but intermittently flickering hearth-fire which is

California, the American Riviera

Don't you hear the West a-calling?

Calling you who have been there before and you who have yet to sense its bewitching charm. The Union Pacific West calls you to a vacation that will live forever in your memory, to the most stupendous, wonderful and beautiful things to see on earth! Geysers hurling columns of boiling spray hundreds of feet skyward, waterfalls with sheer drops of half a mile-mountains, thousands of them thrusting bediamonded peaks from green forests high into cloudless skies. Canyons of bewildering grandeur, filled with gigantic architecture of stone painted with all the colors imaginable! Trees, forests-full of surpassingly big trees that were saplings 5,000 years ago!

Motor trails along the seashore to the heights, to mountain lakes and streams, cool valleys, luxurious but inexpensive highland chalets far from modern smoke and hustle.

And don't forget the cities-they're different too. Denver, the mile high Queen City of the plains; Ogden; Salt Lake City, capital of the Mormons;

Portland, the Rose City; Seattle and Tacoma on lovely Puget Sound; San Francisco by the Golden Gate; Los Angeles, the metropolis of the movies -each with its individual atmosphere and charm.

[ocr errors]

Come out into the West this summer the West of recreation, romance, adventure, mystery, and you will never be satisfied until you return again. And it's not expensive on a low cost independent or Escorted All-Expense Union Pacific tour.

Low Summer Fares via the Cool Summer Route to All the West

California, Yellowstone, Pacific Northwest and Alaska, Colorado, Zion and Grand Canyon National Parks, Bryce Canyon, Ogden, Salt Lake City.

Fill in Coupon and Mail Today---
General Passenger Agent, Dept. 206
Union Pacific System, Omaha, Neb.
Please send me complete information
and booklet.

California Colorado Yellowstone
Zion-Grand Canyon National Parks
Pacific Northwest and Alaska

Dude Ranches

Escorted All-Expense Tours

Name...

Street.

Hawaii

City....

State.

[blocks in formation]
[graphic]

INDEPENDENT

AMERO

500 branches throughout Europe

Itineraries arranged-
Railroad accommoda-
tions-Hotels-Guide
-Automobile-Air
Lines-Write for book-

let giving full particulars

Information may be obtained from all Amerop Agents AMEROP TRAVEL SERVICE, Inc. 574 Fifth Ave., New York 134 N. LaSalle St., Chicago General Agents for Mitteleuropaeisches Reisebuero, G.m.b.H.

[blocks in formation]

common living.

Clarion is the genius
without talent. His need was for "crea-
tive work," and he had no gift for doing
it. When he tried to translate his keenly
appreciated impulses and comprehen-
sions into action, he bungled fatally.

George O'Neil fails to make his char-
acters live, but in the character sketch,
per se, he is extremely successful. The
characters which remain static, the peo-
ple who are caught in a flash and set
down as they were at one given moment,
are admirable: General Sherman, retired |
and entertaining visiting celebrities;
Mme. Drouet, leader of society; Lil,
intellectual prostitute; the colonel, full
of anecdote and juleps. And "That
Bright Heat" is splendid in its recreation
of a lost American scene. It presents a
brilliant picture of St. Louis in the
eighties, that time and place where em-
pire builders, aristocrats, and social
climbers mingled in a society which was
the paradise of the sturdy pioneer or the
glib opportunist, but the intellectual
æsthete's hell. In its physical aspect
that scene has indeed vanished. Spiri-
tually, America has not changed so very
much.

These three novels are unmistakably
the work of poets. E. M. Forster, in a
recent book on the novel, described it in
substance as a sort of cockpit into which
plot and characters are thrown by the
author to fight out the question as to
which shall rule. The poet become nov-
elist concerns himself chiefly with the
construction and embellishment of the
cockpit. The poet's heart is in words.
And there, too, is his treasure. Words,
in his hands, have infinite power. They
can beat upon the sandy stretch of an
arid life and sweep it into a sea of emo-
tion. They can drop on the stone of a
hard heart and wear it away. They can
fall on the good ground of latent talent
and cause it to spring open into bloom.
But they are also the poet-novelist's
danger. Ask the reader of a poet's novel
what he is reading, and too often he can
answer with Hamlet, "Words, words,
words."

Another characteristic of the poet-
novelist is his tendency to maintain a
tense emotional level, permitting himself
none of those stretches of sluggish writ-
ing which are almost essential to the
pure novelist's work. He tends, also, to
strike and sustain one note through his
book. This is clearly illustrated in the
novels under review. Elinor Wylie

strikes and holds the tone of ironic pity.
George O'Neil repeats that of frustra-
tion. Claude McKay hammers with dis-
tressing intensity on the note of bestial-
ity.

The poet-novelist is always a subjec-
tive writer. His plot, if any, is a tenu-

[blocks in formation]

(Aix la Chapelle) Beautiful Rhenish resort for anyone seeking the histor-c and traditional. Hot springs and medical baths for Rheumatic, Articular, and Skin Diseases. Spacious Open all year. grounds. All outdoor sports. Up-to-date hotels. Write for Booklet 1304.

Oeynhausen

The City Without Steps

Beautiful 400-acre park. Alkaline salt springs and
Fango treatments. Heart and Joint Diseases, Rheu-
matism, Gout. Convenient to Hamburg and Bremen.
Open all year.
Write for Booklet 704

Schwalbach

Fashionable, efficacious resort for Heart Ailments,
Anaemia, and Diseases of Women. A favorite
meeting place of American and English society. Ex-
tensive, beautiful forests. Tennis, golf, hunting, and
fishing.
Write for Booklet 1404

(Near Cassel)

Earthy acidulous springs, especially efficacious in the
treatment of Kidney and Bladder Diseases. Dietetic
cuisine in every hotel. Abounding in natural beauty.
All outdoor sports.
Write for Booklet 804

Wiesbaden

GERMANY'S LARGEST RESORT More than 200,000 visitors annually. Social life and historic interests for the tourist. Lectures, concerts, indoor and outdoor sports. Baths, drinking and inhalation cures for Rheumatism, Gout, stomach and Intestinal Troubles. Direct rail connections from all important points of Europe. Write for Booklet 104 GERMAN HEALTH RESORTS 630 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y.

Wanted-To Buy

All old Envelopes with U. S. and Confederate Postage Stamps on them used before year 1880. I pay $1.00 to $10.00 each for old envelopes with pictures of flags, soldiers, etc., on them, used during the war between the North and South from 1861 to 1866. Used or unused stamps before 1880. Send all you have for my inspection or write for surprising information FREE. Address R. V. Rice, 2652 Asbury Ave., Evanston, Ill.

LMS 28

CLASS PINS 350
NEW CATALOG FREE!

DESIGNS SHOWN SILVER PLATE 35 CA $3.50 ooz. STERLING
SILVER 50F EA $5.00 ooz. GOLD PLATE 50 ea. $5.00 DOS
3395 IOA 2 COLORS ENAMEL, ANY LETTERS AND DATE

EMS 28

3499

BASTIAN BROS.CO. 878 BASTIAN BLDG.ROCHESTER.N.Y

[graphic][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed]
[blocks in formation]

IN EUROPE AUTO TOURS IN EUROPE

Dorland Travel Service provides tours throughout Europe. Finest cars with superior

hotels, urs from $6 a day, Tours, inclusive

from $15 a day. Itineraries to suit individual requirements. Road, rail, air tours, steamship and hotel reservations. Information Bureau, Reading Room, etc., free to all visitors. Write for booklet of specimen itineraries and rates to

Outlook Travel Bureau, New York, or
Dorland House, 14 Regent St., London

EUROPE 1928

Student Tours from $275 Select Summer Tours from $775

(High Grade Hotels) PRIVATE MOTOR TOURS Steamship tickets to all parts of the world. Cruises: Mediterranean, West Indies, Bermuda STRATFORD TOURIS

452 Fifth Ave., New York

Major Blake's Tours

England and Continent Cars of every make for hire. Chauffeur or "Drive your own car" arrangement. Offices in leading cities. Free advice. Personal attention. Outlook Travel Bureau or New York Office,

578 Madison Ave.

Send for illustrated folder on Toronto.
Road & Hotel Information, Toronto, Canada

Cuba

F Esq. 15, Vedado.

The Savoy, Havana American plan. Moder

ate. Delightfully located. Well run. Rates,
details, direct, or Outlook Travel Bureau.

England

LONDON ENGLAND

[ocr errors]

Florence Hotel

Lancaster Gate, Hyde Park W 2
Old Established High Class Family Hotel
Especially favored by people of simple tastes.
Famed for quiet comfort and excellent cui-
sine. Situated most convenient and pleasant
part of West End, few yards Hyde Park. All
bedrooms with running hot and cold water.No
charge baths, boots, or attendance. Moderate

Where to Buy or Sell

Where to Travel-How to Travel
Use this Section to Fill Your Wants

New York City
Hotel Wentworth

59 West 46th St., New York City
The hotel you have been looking for
which offers rest, comfortable appointments,
thoughtful cuisine. In the heart of theatre
and shopping center, just off Fifth Ave.
Moderate. Further details, rates, booklets,
direct, or Outlook Travel Bureau.

New York

HURRICANE LODGE and

Cottages

HEART OF THE ADIRONDACKS Hurricane, Essex Co., N. Y. Secluded and accessible. Altitude 1,800 feet. Unsurpassed view of fifty miles Sentinel Range, Whiteface to Marcy. Golf links, saddle horses, swimming pool, tennis. Fresh vegetables, fine dairy. Furnished cottages. Separate Oct. 1. Special rates in June and September. S. Belknap, Manager

suites and single rooms. Open June 14 to

K. Belknap, Secretary Hurricane Lodge
Hurricane, Essex Co., N. Y.

terms for full board or room and breakfast. "Roads End" On Lake

Tariff, etc,, direct or through
Outlook Travel Bureau
Rooms Reserved Against Deposit

The

Connecticut

44

Sacandaga
A camp for the

Where the Trails Begin"
Adirondacks
lovers of the out-of-doors. Refined surround-
ings. Good table. Large living-hall. Cot-
tages and tents for sleeping. Boats and
canoes. Black bass fishing. Hikes into the
woods. Nights around the campfire. Every-
thing comfortable and homelike. CHAS. T.
MEYER,

The Montowese House Lake Pleasant, Hamilton Co., N. Y.

Indian Neck, Branford, Conn.

A very popular family resort, de-
lightfully located, seashore and coun-
try combined, wonderful trees, and
an uninterrupted water view. Boat-

ADIRONDACKS, The CRATER
CLUB, Essex-on Lake Cham-
plain. Cottages with central club house
where meals are served. References required.
For circular or information address JOHN B.
BURNHAM, 233 Broadway, New York City.

AND
COTTAGES

ing, bathing, tennis, music, Interbrook Lodge coAGES

dancing, saddle horses.
Accommodates 250 guests. Send for booklet.

[blocks in formation]

KEENE VALLEY, N. Y.
Located on hill in spruces and pines, 1,500
ft. elevation, oue mile from and 500 ft. above
village on trail to Mt. Marcy. Dancing, tennis,
bathing, fishing, mountain climbing. Golf
course 4 miles. Best moderate-priced hotel in
mountains. Fresh vegetables. State certified
Ayrshire herd. Write for booklet.
B. O. TRYON & SON.

[blocks in formation]
[blocks in formation]

HELP WANTED-Instruction

HOTELS NEED TRAINED MEN AND WOMEN. Nation-wide demand for highsalaried men and women. Past experience unnecessary. We train you by mail and put you in touch with big opportunities. Big pay, fine living, permanent, interesting work, quick advancement. Write for free book, YOUR BIG OPPORTUNITY." Lewis Hotel Training Schools, Suite AT-5842, Washington. D. C.

ADVANCED instruction to C. S. practitioners who can understand that mind is not limited or to those not practitioners who can prove a working knowledge of C. S. practice. ADOLF WERUM, 11 W. 42d St.,

Trapper Lodge, Sixteen-Bar-One Ranch N. Y. C. Telephone Chickering 0171.

Shell, Big Horn Co., Wyoming In Big Horn Mountain cow country. Horseback riding, lake and stream fishing. Our garden and dairy herd supply our table. A complete mountain-top camp maintained. For reservations write GAY WYMAN, Mgr.

A Mart of the Unusual

DELICIOUS CANDY
ELIZABETH DAWSON

Wonderful chocolates. Packed in a beautiful
5-lb. box. $3 delivered. Unheard-of value.
ALLEN & ALLEN, Corning, N. Y.

CLOVER HONEY thick, sweet,

and delicious
Healthful for children and grown-ups. 6
lbs. $1.75; 12 lbs. $3.25. Postpaid
in third zone. Satisfaction guaranteed.
C. LELAND MONIER, Sparland, Ill.

50 Europe-A Delight! Why not-for vest

Evening Dinner and
Sunday noon. $1.00
Double-$5-$6-$7 Luncheon
Special Blue Plate Service in Grill Room
For comfort, for convenience to all parts of
the metropolis, for its famous dining service
come to Hotel Bristol. You'll feel" at home."

Hotel Judson 53 Washington Sq.,
New York City
Residential hotel of highest type, combining
the facilities of hotel life with the comforts of
an ideal home. American plan $4 per day and
up. European plan $1.50 per day and up.
SAMUEL NAYLOR, Manager.

pocket or handbagour memo book? A perfect vade mecumHotels-Routes-Cash Account-Purchases -etc., etc. 120 pages. Reported ideal by many users. Only one dollar by mail. "My " Travel-Log Company, Station C, Buffalo, N.Y.

Harris Tweed

Direct from makers.
Ideal sporting ma-
terial. Any length cut.
Samples free. Newall, 127 Stornoway, Scotland

[blocks in formation]

THE OUTLOOK CLASSIFIED SECTION

CANADIAN girl, 30, desires position as housekeeper or companion. Protestant. Cheerful, capable. References. Pearl Rupert, care Ryan, 202 Grenedier Road, Toronto.

EDUCATED French lady, capable, wishes position in family for summer as companion lady, young girl, or take care children. Could tutor French. Travel or residence. Highest references. 8,400, Outlook.

GRADUATED nurse, German-American, unencumbered, cheerful, excellent traveler, or supervising servants, nurse-companion with couple or gentleman. Highest credentials from distinguished New York doctors. 8,318, Outlook.

GRADUATE nurse, with 15 years' dietetic experience in hospital sanatorium and institutional work, desires to be placed in summer camp work in connection with the feeding. Location in the East preferred. 8,361, Outlook.

SITUATIONS WANTED

LADY, capable and dependable, wishes position as companion to elderly lady or working housekeeper to elderly couple or business man or woman without children. 8,387, Outlook.

POSITION as companion; free to travel after July 1. References exchanged. 8,346, Outlook.

POSITION as dietitian, or assistant, camp dining-room. Cornell graduate. 8,395, Outlook. PRIVATE teacher, middle-aged; companion, family assistant, directing children's studies, music, languages. 8,399, Outlook.

REFINED, educated girl desires position as governess. Free from present position July 1. Musical education. References exchanged. 8,345, Outlook.

REFINED North Carolina girl, college graduate, interested in outdoor life, desires position as governess or traveling companion for summer. 8,371, Outlook.

UNIVERSITY professor, on leave, will accept a few correspondence students in harmony, counterpoint, or musical appreciation. For further information address 8,394, Outlook.

WOMAN, educated, experienced, as gov-
erness-companion, mother's assistant. 8,401,
Outlook.

YOUNG Smith College graduate desires
position as companion, tutor, or secretary on
European or other trip. Speaks French and
Spanish. Post Office Box 1070, New Haven,
Conn.

SOCIAL TRAINING

SOCIAL economic independence assured men and women who will use the instructions I have to offer in APPLIED METAPHYSICS with "fixed principle, a given rule, and unmistakable proof." ADOLF WERUM, 11 W. 42d St., N. Y. C. Telephone Chickering 0171.

MISCELLANEOUS

NIFTY scientific bird houses: Blue bird, $1.25; wren, $1.50; postpaid. Box 270, Jamestown, N. Y.

TO young women desiring training in the care of obstetrical patients a nine months' nurses' aid course is offered by the Lying-In Hospital, 307 Second Ave., New York. Aids are provided with maintenance and given a monthly allowance of $10. For further par ticulars address Directress of Nurses.

WILL take small baby in private home in beautiful village, thirty minutes from New York City. Love and efficient care. High-st references. P. O. Box 352, Ridgewood, N. J.

CLUB papers, speeches, articles prepared. Authors' Research, 500 Fifth Ave., N. f.

ous thread; his characters, a parade of types, ample or limited according to his personal experience; but his atmosphere, his emotional key, is unfailing and unmistakable. He looks in his heart and writes. He looks in his heart and knows himself as many creatures in one child, tyrant, mother, lover, martyr and fallen angel, and failure and success. So that he can match any joy and any sorrow with a joy and sorrow of his own, and knows by heart the words and music of any triumphal chant, pæan of praise, or dirge. Thus he becomes the inevitable protagonist of all his novels. Each one of them is his spiritual autobiography.

Why Is a Best-Seller?

(Continued from page 634)

haven't reached me." With $40,000 in royalties coming his way and a press book jammed with laudations, such unawareness constitutes an excellent protective device against diversion from his craft.

He is a slight man of medium height, or less. His manner is divided between boyish naïveté, as when he would burst. out with an expression of delight at the sensation of being interviewed, and scholarly introspection, as when he was analyzing the literary influences which have helped shape his style. His slight mustache and large tortoise-shell glasses seem to be his chief physical characteristics. He speaks in eager streaks of animated conversation. It is possible that the success of "The Bridge" will take a little more time in penetrating his consciousness, after which his manner will adjust itself to the consciousness of success, and then we shall have a new Wilder. For the present we have a prebest-seller Wilder. And it is this Wilder who, when asked whether his plans for the future included the surrender of his school post, said:

"Partly because I have a routine I enjoy and teaching is rightly a man's full day's work-I cannot think of giving up

640

teaching for writing. When one considers the milieu against which the writing career may develop, teaching is as good as any. The New England background from which I come is not friendly to the idea of retiring to the Riviera and writing exclusively. Writing in itself is not a sufficient occupation in a world in which there is so much to do. It is not in the New England conscience to be a writer

The Movies

(See page 627)

"The Battles of Coronel and Falkland Islands.”— A British film; well worth your while. "Beau_Sabreur."-Pepless desert drama. "The Big City."-Lon Chaney in a flat picture. Maybe some one stepped on it. "Chicago."-See what the movies can do when they try.

"The Circus."-Charlie Chaplin's newest, and one of his best.

"The Count of Ten."-James Gleason and Charles Ray in a good ring drama.

"The Crowd."-King Vidor is a great director. The story is slim and depressing.

"Czar Ivan the Terrible."-Hectic, but interesting Russian-made film.

"The Divine Woman."-Greta Garbo has a tough time with this one.

"Dressed to Kill."-Excellent crook melodrama. "Drums of Love."-A big eyeful from D. W. Griffith.

"Finders Keepers."-Laura La Plante, and some hard-pressed humor.

"Four Sons."-Beauty, skill, tears, and hokum. "The Gaucho."-Douglas Fairbanks. "Gentlemen Prefer Blondes."-Plenty of chuckles for the business man.

"A Girl in Every Port."-A pretty feeble vehicle for the large Victor McLaglen. "The Jazz Singer."-Al Jolson + Vitaphone Price of Admission.

=

"The Last Command."-Emil Jannings in a picture worthy of him.

"The Last Moment."-Interesting

tricks, if you like them.

photographic

"The Latest from Paris."-Something pleasantly innocuous, with Norma Shearer. "The Legion of the Condemned."-After "Wings." A long way after.

"Love Me and the World is Mine."-For insomniacs and very young cash-girls. "Mother Machree."-For the Irish vote.

nice.

Very

"The Noose."-A pretty fair Richard Barthelmess picture.

"Red Hair."-Clara Bow and Elinor Glyn. Decide as you see fit. "Rose Marie."-Run!

Here's the Mounted Police

again. "Sadie Thompson.”-Gloria Swanson and Lionel Barrymore trying not to play "Rain." "The Secret Hour."-"They Knew What

They Wanted" dolled up for the screen with Pola Negri and Jean Hersholt. Good. "The Showdown."-Tropical mix-up, and how. "Simba."-See it-you'll thank us.

"The Smart Set."-You'll die outside, seeking air. "Soft Living."-A nice enough little drama, with Madge Bellamy.

"The Student Prince."-A Lubitsch production. Don't miss it. "Sunrise."-The best picture on any screen today. "Tenderloin."-The talking picture. They'll have to do better.

"That's My Daddy."-Reginald Denny in a pleas

ant farce.

"The Trail of '98."-Big Alaskan melodrama, with some grand scenes.

"Two Lovers."-Ronald Colman and Vilma Banky in a romantic picture of the sixteenth century. "We Americans."-Melting-pot drama with good

spots.

"Wings."-A war picture with a big wallop.

and not have some valuable daily task. Perhaps I began writing too late to acquire the habit of working, say, from nine to noon. My idea is to write briefly and only intermittently, against the background of a useful job."

From his publishers I learn that he is planning to do something very serioussomething that may take him as many as four or five years to complete. He cannot tell them whether it will be an obscure or a simple book, a mystical or a realistic book. To me he said that he would like to do a child's book, and, later in the interview: "I would like to do a picaresque novel, for which the chapter on Uncle Pio is a hasty sketch. I should like to do his boyhood especially the case of a purely parasitic, conscienceless gifted boy who carves out through endless trials and errors his own odd but convincing rules of right and wrong. The background would be the shady side of all Europe."

Is America, I asked, turning to the introspective novelist? According to Wilder, the rule of the realist is ended. It was from his lips that I heard the most philosophical explanation for the success of "The Bridge," although it was not presented in that light. “Until about ten years ago," said Wilder, "experience was very valuable as a preparation toward the writing of novels. Authors who had been stokers and barhands did bring something valuable to America in the process of discovering itself. But now the notation of objects has been done so well through such men as Sinclair Lewis that from now on the profounder assimilation of a little experience rather than a rapid view of a great deal is the more desirable. Literature, now that America has discovered itself, could spring from solitude and reflection, with less emphasis on observation and more on intuition." He cited the example of Emily Brontë, who, living all her life in a little village back yard, wrote novels that suggest experience of a universal order. From Sinclair Lewis to Thornton Wilder!

PRINTED IN U. S. A. BY ART COLOR PRINTING COMPANY, DUNELLEN, N. J.

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small]

THE OUTLOOK, April 25, 1928. Volume 148, Number 17. Published weekly by The Outlook Company at 120 East 16th Street, New York, N. Y. Subscription price $5.00 a year. Single copies 15 cents each. Foreign subscription to countries in the postal Union, $6.56. Entered as second-class matter, July 21, 1893, at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., and December 1, 1926, at the Post Office at Dunellen, N. J., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1928, by The Outlook Company.

Two things struck us forcibly as we finished reading Judge Lindsey's article on Companionate Marriage, printed in this issue. The first was the immense price in courage, strength, reputation, and peace of mind-which Judge Lindsey has had to pay for advancing a social idea which his experience has convinced him is valuable. The second was the astounding fact that, despite all the ignorant hue and cry, the editorials, sermons, arguments, letters, speeches, scarcely a few thousand of us have read his book and actually know what he is talking about.

Is a man, then, right or wrong, to be shouted down by ignorance, passion, prejudice? Is that the best an educated democracy can do with any proposed solution which involves genuine differences of opinion? Even one proposed by an admittedly honest man, a good citizen, and a reputable judge?

It would seem so.

PREACHERS have used Judge Lindsey's suggestion to draw crowds. Magazines have printed dozens of articles which reinforce current views on the subject of marriage, and so have secured more subscribers. Newspapers have reported everything which possessed even a faint hint of anything startling concerning his proposal—and so raised their circulation. But not one person in ten thousand has taken the pains to read Judge Lindsey's book and honestly and carefully weigh the merit of his suggestion. Even the magazine which originally printed his articles used them only for sensational purposes, and made no sincere effort to examine their worth as a solution for a social problem.

AND what is this revolutionary proposal of Judge Lindsey? "Legal marriage with legalized birth control and with the right to divorce by mutual consent for childless couples, usually without payment of alimony."

THE editors of The Outlook have not yet made up their minds in their judgment of Judge Lindsey's proposal. All the evidence is not yet in. But we are glad to print this statement of a man who has admittedly given more thought to the subject than have most of us, and who has the courage to advance his conclusions. In our view, the outcry against him is both disgraceful and absurd.

[blocks in formation]

Index and title-page for Volume 148 (January 4-April 25, 1928) of The Outlook, printed separately for binding, will be furnished gratis, on application, to any reader who desires them for this purpose

« PreviousContinue »